3PL exclusivity: what can you still send to another provider?
Exclusivity can restrict channels, regions or order allocation even when no monthly minimum is missed. Define what stays flexible before committing volume.
Accept a 3PL exclusivity commitment only when its scope matches the work you intend to award and the benefit justifies the flexibility you give up. Define the covered products, channels, territories and period. Preserve any agreed exceptions for existing providers, specialist services, new channels and disruption response before placing inventory.
Exclusivity is separate from a monthly minimum. A brand might pay every required invoice and still have a disagreement about sending orders elsewhere. Conversely, a non-exclusive arrangement can still have minimum charges. Ask the provider to explain both provisions independently, then have the final agreement reviewed for the actual transaction.
Describe the business you are committing
Start with a channel-and-region allocation sheet. List DTC, wholesale, marketplace replenishment, supplier direct shipments and any internal operation. Mark which work the new provider will receive on day one and which work remains elsewhere. Include acquired brands or future channels only if the parties deliberately intend to include them.
Words such as “all fulfillment” can hide different assumptions. A merchant may mean its current domestic DTC operation; a bidder may price against a wider volume pool. Clarify whether the commitment attaches to a legal entity, storefront, brand, product family or destination. Document exceptions with enough detail to identify actual orders.
Use the operating profile requested by 247's custom pricing overview to separate channels, product work and shipping needs. A request for pricing does not itself establish that 247 requires exclusivity or offers a discount for it. Confirm the terms of your specific proposal.
Compare the commercial structures separately
| Proposed term | What it addresses | Question to settle |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly minimum | Minimum eligible spend | What shortfall remains payable? |
| Volume forecast or reservation | Planning for expected work | What capacity is confirmed and on what assumptions? |
| Exclusive award | Which provider may perform covered work | What orders can still go elsewhere? |
| Preferred-provider arrangement | Priority or first opportunity to quote | Is there a matching, response or refusal process? |
These are comparison categories, not statements that every agreement uses the same definitions. Ask for a plain-language example alongside the proposed wording. The existing minimum-charge guide helps calculate a spend floor; it cannot determine whether a separate allocation restriction has been satisfied.
Model the volume you can actually award
Hypothetical CAD example, not a 247 offer. A brand forecasts 12,000 monthly orders. It intends to keep 2,000 specialist orders with an existing provider, leaving 10,000 for the new 3PL. Assume a non-exclusive handling rate of CAD $2.50 and an exclusive rate of $2.30 for the same included work. Other charges, postage and taxes are excluded.
If the specialist orders are expressly outside the commitment, the handling comparison on the awarded 10,000 orders is CAD $25,000 versus $23,000: a hypothetical CAD $2,000 monthly difference. It is incorrect to apply the discount to all 12,000 orders when 2,000 will never reach that warehouse.
Now assume the brand wants a second provider to handle 1,500 of the remaining orders during promotions. Only 8,500 would reach the new 3PL. At an agreed non-exclusive $2.50 rate, that portion costs CAD $21,250. The second provider's handling, storage, transfer and integration costs must be added separately. This number alone cannot establish whether splitting the work is cheaper.
Under an exclusive proposal, do not assume that paying the original minimum makes that 1,500-order diversion permitted. Obtain the agreed treatment before comparing savings. Price any specified consequences using the actual proposal; an invented penalty would make the decision model less useful.
Negotiate exceptions that can be executed
List the circumstances in which another provider may be used. Examples to discuss include unsupported products, a new destination market, a retailer-mandated service, an agreed volume above confirmed capacity, or a defined interruption. Give each exception a trigger, notice method and decision owner. “Emergency overflow allowed” is difficult to execute if nobody knows who can authorize it.
For a temporary diversion, decide when the exception begins, how covered orders are identified and what closes it. If the primary provider resumes service, establish how new orders return without sending duplicates or stranding inventory. A contractual exception supplies permission; a tested secondary operation supplies practical capability.
Check whether a backup is usable
Ask whether you may maintain an integration, limited stock and periodic test orders at a second provider. A dormant warehouse relationship without inventory or a validated order path offers little immediate relief. Include the cost of keeping that option ready, while recognizing that ordinary backup readiness is different from moving the whole operation.
Separate the allocation decision from network geography. Two warehouses managed by one contracted provider and two independently contracted providers create different commercial relationships. The buyer's question here is who may receive the work, even if both candidate facilities are in the same market.
Resolve the allocation schedule before the final quote
Bring the bidder an actual order allocation, known exclusions, forecast range and proposed backup use. Ask it to price that scope and identify assumptions that would change the offer. Have your advisers review exclusivity, permitted exceptions and the interaction with minimums, renewal and termination in the final agreement.
If you are evaluating 247 Fulfillment, explain the work you plan to retain in-house or with another partner alongside the work available for the proposal. A clear award is easier to price than a headline volume that includes orders the provider will never handle.
We fulfill from Toronto, Vancouver, Utah and Florida, with Ohio opening Q4 2026. See what it would cost for your orders.
Keep reading
All articlesBuyer guides · 3 min read
Musical-instrument fulfillment: shipping checks versus specialist setup
A successful barcode scan does not establish that an instrument is ready to play. Compare the accepted shipping condition and any specialist prepar...
Buyer guides · 3 min read
Framed-art fulfillment: who inspects glazing and protects the artwork?
Evaluate the framed object as separate surfaces and components. Agree what may be touched, opened, inspected and repacked before comparing handling...
Buyer guides · 3 min read
Mattress fulfillment: compare compressed shipping and expanded returns
A compressed outbound carton does not define the work or space required for an expanded mattress return. Evaluate both physical flows before choosi...


















FedEx
UPS