Published November 21, 2026 · 3 min read

Can you outsource only part of your catalogue to a 3PL?

Keeping bespoke products in-house can work alongside a 3PL for standard stock. Test whole customer baskets and retained costs before deciding where the boundary belongs.

247 Fulfillment TeamFulfillment centers in Canada and the U.S.
Editorial illustration of an embroidered pouch in an open black box beside sealed kraft shipping cartons.
Original editorial illustration

You can outsource part of a catalogue when the merchant and provider agree which products and orders each operation owns. The deciding test is whether actual customer baskets can cross that boundary without expensive extra shipments, duplicated work or ambiguous responsibility. Keeping bespoke products in-house may be sensible; assuming every order will stay neatly on one side is the risky part.

This arrangement suits a brand with two genuinely different work profiles: repeatable stocked goods and products needing customization, founder approval or specialist preparation. Before seeking a quote, define the retained work and replay past orders through the proposed split. A SKU list alone will miss customers who buy from both groups.

Draw the operating boundary before comparing prices

Write one sentence for each operation: what it stores, what work it performs and what it releases to the customer. For example, a brand could retain made-to-order embroidery while a provider ships finished accessories. That is a hypothetical scope, not a statement that any particular provider has accepted the products or workflows.

Then choose how mixed baskets work. You might send separate parcels, move completed bespoke items to the provider for consolidation, or keep every mixed order in-house. Each option changes handling, transit time and stock needs. Consolidation introduces a physical transfer; keeping mixed orders requires access to the standard items at the retained operation.

The broader in-house versus 3PL cost comparison helps distinguish costs you can avoid from costs you will retain. Apply that distinction separately to the catalogue segment you propose to outsource.

Replay customer baskets rather than counting SKUs

Hypothetical monthly example: 2,000 customer orders include 1,400 standard-only baskets, 400 bespoke-only baskets and 200 mixed baskets. Assume all products are available, each operation sends one parcel for its part, and every mixed basket is split.

The provider receives work for 1,600 customer orders: 1,400 standard-only plus 200 mixed. The retained team handles 600: 400 bespoke-only plus 200 mixed. Together they perform 2,200 fulfillment jobs and send 2,200 parcels for 2,000 customer orders. The extra 200 parcels arise from mixed baskets, not growth in sales.

If those extra parcels cost a hypothetical CAD $7 each, the split adds CAD $1,400 in postage before any additional packing material, customer support or transfer cost. This is an incremental illustration, not a carrier quote or a complete comparison. Existing parcel sizes and destination profiles could change the result substantially.

Test the other arrangements against the same 200 mixed baskets. A transfer may replace extra postage with transport, receiving and waiting time. Keeping mixed baskets at the brand may require duplicate stock and continued picking labour. Compare the total work instead of treating consolidation as free.

Use an ownership worksheet

Handoff Question to settle Useful evidence
New order Who owns each item and the customer promise? Three basket examples with assigned work
Cancellation Who stops both operations? Acknowledgment before release
Mixed dispatch How are both parcel states visible? Customer service view of a split order
Return Who can inspect and restock each item? Accepted return destination and task list

For each row, name one accountable party and the evidence that closes the task. A customer cancellation can affect two operations even when neither has shipped. A partial dispatch can leave the other operation holding the rest of the basket. Decide how customer service sees that state before it promises a refund or replacement.

Returns need a similar boundary. Establish where a mixed order is returned, who identifies the components and whether the receiving operation is authorized to inspect or restock goods normally held elsewhere. Sending everything to one address is convenient only if the accepted scope supports the resulting work.

Price what actually disappears from the retained operation

A partial move rarely removes every retained expense. If bespoke work still needs the same lease, equipment and supervisor, those costs remain in the combined model. Count a labour reduction only when the schedule, overtime or role actually changes. If freed capacity supports additional production, show that as a separate business benefit with its own assumptions.

Request a provider quote for the outsourced segment's actual monthly jobs, units, receipts and storage. Check minimum charges against that segment, not total brand sales. Include extra mixed-basket packing, return handling and any transfer receiving. A low base fee cannot resolve an operating boundary that creates repeated manual intervention.

Ask how additional products can enter the outsourced scope later. A brand may retain bespoke work permanently or use a partial move as a measured first stage. Avoid a plan that depends on an unpriced future migration to become economical.

Prove the handoff before moving stock

Use the 247 integration overview to frame a technical discussion, then request evidence for your particular arrangement. Do not assume a standard connection automatically handles custom routing, split cancellations or two return destinations. Demonstrate a standard basket, a bespoke basket and a mixed basket through dispatch and cancellation.

Prefer the partial arrangement when specialist work genuinely needs to stay with the brand and mixed-basket costs remain acceptable. Reconsider it when most customers buy across both groups, retained costs barely change or the two operations cannot share reliable order status. An all-in move or a different catalogue boundary may then be simpler.

Send 247 your proposed retained and outsourced scopes, with a representative order export identifying mixed baskets. Ask which work can be accepted and how exceptions would be handled before requesting a final proposal.

Keep reading

All articles